Dear Friends,
This is a contrarian view expressed by a Sinhalese writer. He argues
that no powers should devolved to the Provincial Councils (PC). President Rajapaksa has
now joined this fanatical crowd and made a U-turn on what he promised
S.M.Krishna a couple of days ago. At an interaction on Monday
with the country's editors at Temple Trees, the President's official residence,
Mr. Rajapaksa “denied that he ever told India” that he would devolve powers
under the 13th Amendment.
Asked if he meant the Indian side lied about his purported
promise during his meeting with Indian Foreign Minister S.M. Krishna, Mr.
Rajapaksa said: “This is not the first time that I am saying it [that I am for
implementing the 13th Amendment]. In the beginning I said I have no objection.
But Tamil parties should come and give their names to the PSC and decide on
it…what they want. So the PSC advises and tells me ‘this is what you must do,'
we have no objection. Parliament should do it. This is not my personal issue…I
am ready to accept anything that Parliament gives me. Because Parliament
consists of all parties...so they have to decide on this…Let all the official
parties, the TNA, and all these people get together…”
Now Rajapaksa is finding an escape route by pushing the responsibility
to PSC. This is how all deliberations in the past 64 years ended. The Bandaranaike-Chelvanayakam Pact
of 1957, Senanayake-Chelvanayakam Pact of
1965 were both unilaterally abrogated by the Sinhalese before even the ink
dried up on the paper. If S.M.Krishna believes that the Tamils should settle
their differences amicably through dialogue, he is obviously living in a world
of his own wishful thinking.
Now the
government wants the Tamil party, TNA, to nominate its representatives to PSC
and start negotiations, which would drag on aimlessly for years without any
conclusion. Meanwhile colonisation of Tamil Homeland will continue until the
Tamils are totally subjugated. No Tamil party should ever engage in any
dialogue in the PSC, as the majority of its members are Sinhalese diehards and
it will bring no benefit to the Tamils.
If the Delhi
Pundits have any more morality or decency left in them, they should not object
to the Sinhalese criminals dragged into the International Criminal Court in
Hague. After helping the Sinhalese to remove the only protection the Tamils
had, Prabhakaran and the LTTE, they should the next best; restore the Eelam
Tamil rights in their Homeland. Anything short of that is a crime committed by
India against the Tamil race.
Far from it,
New Delhi has now announced an Annual Defence Dialogue, aiming to enhance bilateral defence cooperation and
to discuss the regional security situation. Where do all these leave
the Tamils?
Visvanathan
Is 13th
Amendment to the Constitution practicable?
Posted on June 8th, 2009
By
S. Akurugoda, Melbourne, Australia
Posted on June 8th, 2009
At his last official press briefing at the Ministry
of Justice last week, outgoing Chief Justice Sarath Nanda Silva described that
the 13th Amendment to the Constitution as ill-conceived and hurriedly pieced
together by picking bits and pieces of the Indian Constitution in keeping with
the Indo-Lanka Accord and hence was not practicable.
Since India was a large country, devolution of
power was essential for her but it was not so for a small country like Sri
Lanka, the Chief Justice said adding that devolution of police and land powers
was not at all suitable for Sri Lanka.
Expression of personal judgment on the 13th
Amendment, in his capacity as Chief Justice, is timely. Although the statement
is not a court ruling, the statement is an eye opener to those politicians
(including government ministers) who blindly parroting the words “the
implementation of the 13th Amendment” without knowing what is in it. Today we
have even cabinet ministers claiming it is Mr. Mahinda Rajapaksa who made both
Sinhala and Tamil official languages and trying to find fault with Mr. S.W.R.D
Bandaranaike, the founder leader of his own political party, for making Sinhala
the official language. The particular minister is either not aware that it is
the 13th amendment which made Tamil an official language overnight or he is
trying to mislead people.
According to various other reports, the government
was in favour of full implementation of the 13th amendment. Those who promote
its implementation argue that the Amendment already exists and what is needed
is implementation. The ill-fated, ill-defined and hastily prepared 17th
Amendment to the Constitution is a minor case in point of attempting to
implement anything, just because it is in the constitution, compared to the
disastrous consequences that could be expected by devolving power on ethnic
lines.
Background of the 13th Amendment
All parties appear to have forgotten the background
against which the 13th Amendment to the Constitution came into being and most
of them may not be aware of what really is in the 13th Amendment since the
Indo-Lanka pact was signed two decades ago.
Indo-Lanka relations deteriorated as never before
after 1977, mainly due to the short-sighted policies adopted by the UNP
government. The book ‘Assignment Colombo’ written by J. N.
Dixit, the former Indian High commissioner to Sri Lanka (1985-1989), outlining
his version of the story, tells us how and why the Indian government went all
out to coerce Sri Lanka into submission.
Indian cargo planes invaded Sri Lanka’s air space
challenging the sovereignty of our country, and almost forced former president
JR Jayawardena (JR) to ‘invite’ Rajiv Gandhi to Sri Lanka to sign the agreement
and to accept the Indian Peace Keeping Force (IPKF). Sri Lanka had no
alternative but to ‘surrender’ to India’s demands and sign a hurriedly prepared
document endorsed by the Tamil separatist groups including the LTTE.
The JR-Rajiv pact was not transparent like the CFA
signed by Ranil and Prabhakaran and the main Opposition political parties were
not consulted or briefed on the contents of agreement at any stage. The
JR-Rajiv Pact was signed amidst curfew and the function was boycotted by the
Prime Minister R. Premadasa and Cabinet ministers including Lalith
Athulathmudali, who was in-charge of National Security. Political parties such
as SLFP, JVP, MEP, including a section of the UNP, were against the agreement
and the extent of the opposition to the treacherous agreement was notable when
a sailor attacked the Indian PM while the latter was receiving the guard of
honour. An estimated 65,000 lives, mainly Sinhala youth, were lost as a result
of subsequent uprising.
Those UNP parliamentarians who opposed the
Indo-Lanka Accord, which paved the way for the 13th Amendment had no
alternative but to vote for it since JR had already taken them ‘political
hostage’ by keeping undated resignation letters signed by MPs in his pocket.
The only gentleman parliamentarian who had the
backbone to resign in protest and leave politics completely was the late Mr.
Gamini Jayasuriya.
The SLFP under the leadership of Mrs. Sirima
Bandaranaike was totally against the India-Sri Lanka Accord and the Provincial
Councils and that party, in fact, boycotted the first the Provincial Council
elections.
What is in it?
The goal of the 13th Amendment was to make
provisions for setting up of a Provincial Council for each Province;
establishment of a High Court for each Province; and making Tamil an official
language and English the link language.
The 37 subjects devolved to Provincial Councils are
given in the List I (and also in the List III – Concurrent List) of the Ninth
Schedule. These include all the subjects other than those retained by the
government (the List II or the Reserved List).
The subjects retained under the Centre include
National Policy on Security, Foreign Affairs, Posts and Telecommunications,
Broadcasting, Television, Justice in so far as it relates to the judiciary and
the courts structure, Finance in relation to national revenue, monetary policy
and external resources; Customs, Foreign Trade, Inter Province Trade and
Commerce, Ports and Aviation, National Transport, Minerals and Mines,
Immigration and Emigration and Citizenship, Immigration and Emigration and
Citizenship, Elections, Census and Statistics, National Archives,
Archaeological Activities and Sites and Antiquities declared by or under any
law made by Parliament to be of National Importance, Rivers and Waterways,
Shipping and Navigation, Maritime zones including Historical Waters,
Territorial Waters, Exclusive Economic zone and Continental Shelf and Internal
Waters, State Lands and Foreshore except to the extent specified in Item 18 of
List I.
It would be easier to write down the powers
remaining in the Centre (as above) since the powers devolved (are to be devolved)
are enormous. Powers yet to be handed over include police and Land and
Judiciary.
A brief comparison with Indian
Constitution
India has been called as a Union of States. In
spite of having a federal structure, there is a strong bias towards making the
Central government more powerful. This is called a Centralised Federation’ or a
Quasi – Federal Government, that is partly federal and partly unitary.
There is clear division of powers stated under the
three lists – Union list, State list and Concurrent list. Also, there is an
independent and impartial judiciary to solve conflicts between the Central and
State governments.
The Parliament has vast legislative powers. It can
legislate on 97 subjects of the union list, 47 subjects of the concurrent list
and in times of national and state emergency; it can also make laws on the 66
subjects of the state list. If there is a conflict between a union law and a
state law over a subject present in the Concurrent list, the law made by the
Parliament will prevail over the law made by the state legislatures!
The President of India has vast emergency powers.
He can declare national, state and financial emergency. The Governor of a state
acts as an agent of the President. He is appointed by the President and can be
recalled by him. The Governor can advise the President to impose emergency in
the state. During an emergency, the Governor carries out the administration on
behalf of the President. He can also refer some bills to the President.
The state governments are dependent upon the
Central government for funds and grants. These are allocated by the Planning
Commission and the Finance Commission which are central bodies.
The members of the All Indian Services are
appointed by the Union Public Service Commission, which is a central body.
Although the officers are posted in the states, they continue to owe their
loyalty to the government.
As can be seen, there is hardly any difference
between the Quasi-Federal Indian government and the form of government forced
on us by the Indian constitutional draftsmen.
Failure of 13th Amendment and India’s
commitments
Prior to the signing of the 13th Amendment, there
had been a belief that the ‘Official language policy” of 1956 was the root
cause of the conflict. The 13th Amendment made Tamil an official language
overnight as a solution but the charges against discrimination and demand for
self-determination continue to be made based on those lines. If official
language is the root cause, the conflict would have resolved itself with the implementation
of the 13th Amendment language policy.
Although the Indian government undertook to disarm
the terrorists group in return of implementing the constitutional amendment
imposed on the Sri Lanka government, India has failed miserably to fulfill its
obligation as per the agreement. On the other hand, Sri Lankan people had to
bear the huge cost of war against terror and the cost of implementing the
constitution amendment, thus imposed under the failed agreement, in addition to
the loss of lives since 1987. Since it is the Sri Lankan Security forces who
ultimately disarm the terrorists, the moral rights of the Indian government to
ask the government of Sri Lanka to implement 13th amendment is highly
questionable.
Conclusion
There is, no doubt, that the Indian Civil servants
who drafted the Indo-Lanka pact have been influenced by the Indian
Quasi-Federal system.
In fact, some argue that the Indian Constitution
has vested more powers with the Centre than those made under the 13th amendment
in this country and when implemented in full Sri Lanka’s system will surpass
the Indian’s quasi-federal system.
Thus, the unitary nature of our Constitution was
shattered with the establishment of Provincial Councils. The powers once
devolved, especially along ethnic lines, though the Centre has the power to
dissolve any provincial council, will be irreversible and, if an attempt is
made to reverse them, the consequence would be disastrous.
During the establishment of Eastern Provincial
Council, we witnessed how elections were manipulated by the political parties
formed and named on communal basis and how the positions were claimed purely on
communal basis by the very same groups. Segregating people according to
communal lines under the name of devolution could only strengthen the hands of
separatist movements still alive.
President Rajapaksa said at the ceremonial opening
of the Fourth Session of the Sixth Parliament last month stressed the necessity
of finding a solution that is very own and it cannot be an imported solution.
He further stressed that he does not have time to be experimenting with the
solutions suggested by other countries and any solution should be acceptable to
all sections of the people.
Thus the 13th Amendment to the Constitution, forced
on us by India, is certainly imported and not of our own. Further, the
Amendment is not acceptable to all sections of the people. As the Chief justice
quite rightly identified, the Amendment as ill-conceived and hurriedly pieced
together by picking bits and pieces of the Indian Constitution in keeping with
the Indo-Lanka Accord and hence was not practicable.
No comments:
Post a Comment